Window button replacement "fun"

MartinThorn

Active Member
Feb 28, 2024
89
29
Afternoon! Had an intermittent driver's window button so replaced it with a new one off the usual auction site (very cheap).
Went ok.. but was moderate amount of swearing trying to get the door card off which you have to do in order to replace the buttons!

My experience - some door cards are harder to 'simply pop off' than the Youtube videos seem to show! Mine was stuck like a limpet* and when it did finally seperate, there was a small shower of plastic thanks to disintegrating trim grommets (the ones that were reluctant to come away from the car!).

So what would my advice be? Perhaps consider as well as the switches, buying a few spare front door trim clips too!

I've left mine with two/three in sub-optimal condition that may be replaced later if there's unwanted buzzing/rattling.

Electric window works again though!

*I was using several plastic bike tire levers so not exactly a trim tool but pretty close
 

SuperV8

Active Member
May 30, 2019
1,692
807
Plastic goes brittle when cold - so best doing this in the warmer weather - or indoors - obviously not always the option!
But yes - I would assume you may break some and have some spares handy.
 

MartinThorn

Active Member
Feb 28, 2024
89
29
Plastic goes brittle when cold - so best doing this in the warmer weather - or indoors - obviously not always the option!
But yes - I would assume you may break some and have some spares handy.
Yes, cold and old plastic not a great combination! And yes, she-who-must-be-obeyed wanted it fixed so couldn't wait for warmer weather..
 

BillyCool

Active Member
Jan 16, 2020
724
296
Leicestershire, UK
I took my drivers door card off to change a wing mirror and mangled some of the clips. I bought some more but not fitted them yet. Over time (3 years) the door card is starting to rattle. I think that when the weather gets better I'll finally fit the new clips.
 

DEAN0

Old Git
Feb 1, 2006
5,392
378
Preston - UK
I will never remove a VW/SEAT/AUDI/SKODA door card without a pack of new clips in my tool box.

At £6.29 for 20 - it is not worth risking how many will get broken in the process

 

Mr Pig

Active Member
Jun 17, 2015
2,796
1,022
I will never remove a VW/SEAT/AUDI/SKODA door card without a pack of new clips in my tool box.

At £6.29 for 20 - it is not worth risking how many will get broken in the process

Those must be the only trim clips I do not have! Why are there so many kinds? Wouldn't a couple of different ones done the job?
 

MartinThorn

Active Member
Feb 28, 2024
89
29
I will never remove a VW/SEAT/AUDI/SKODA door card without a pack of new clips in my tool box.

At £6.29 for 20 - it is not worth risking how many will get broken in the process

And none of the Youtube videos that I watched mentioned needing to buy them!
 

MartinThorn

Active Member
Feb 28, 2024
89
29
Hmm.. at night, the lighting within the new drivers side window switches are white.. but my other original switches on other doors are red! Now I'm wondering if it was always like that or have I installed a slightly incorrect variant (that works fine)!?
 

SRGTD

Active Member
May 26, 2014
2,640
1,487
Hmm.. at night, the lighting within the new drivers side window switches are white.. but my other original switches on other doors are red! Now I'm wondering if it was always like that or have I installed a slightly incorrect variant (that works fine)!?

I suspect the original that you replaced had red backlighting like the others in your car.
 

Craig.

The artist formally known as ViperSlider
Mar 26, 2024
243
200
Cardiff, S.Wales
Hmm.. at night, the lighting within the new drivers side window switches are white.. but my other original switches on other doors are red! Now I'm wondering if it was always like that or have I installed a slightly incorrect variant (that works fine)!?
Sounds like you've fitted VW golf switches (or similar) as the golf interior is illuminated white

I think it's Golf, I'll check my notes lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: SRGTD

Craig.

The artist formally known as ViperSlider
Mar 26, 2024
243
200
Cardiff, S.Wales
 

SRGTD

Active Member
May 26, 2014
2,640
1,487
Sounds like you've fitted VW golf switches (or similar) as the golf interior is illuminated white

I think it's Golf, I'll check my notes lol

The window switches in my 2020 Polo GTI+ had white illumination. With the Golf, VW changed to white illuminated switches with the mk7 (the switches in my Mk4, Mk5 and Mk6 Golfs all had red illumination).
 

MartinThorn

Active Member
Feb 28, 2024
89
29
Sounds like you've fitted VW golf switches (or similar) as the golf interior is illuminated white

I think it's Golf, I'll check my notes lol

Yes, that will be it. Didn't think to check illumination colour - not that it matters too much anyway! Just had that strange feeling something wasn't quite right.. took me a good 20 minutes or so to figure out what it was!
 

DEAN0

Old Git
Feb 1, 2006
5,392
378
Preston - UK
And none of the Youtube videos that I watched mentioned needing to buy them!
Theoretically - they are re-useable.
You re-set them and then re-install them.

However - in reality - at least one seems to get broken.

I have just got in to the habit of keeping a pack in the garage.
 
Adrian Flux insurance services - discount for forum members.