I appreciate that, but you earlier posted this regarding gearboxes:wicca said:...because now the car is making 130ft/lb of torque...with the turbo it would be twice the amount...
The two posts just seem to contradict each other. I'm curious how you've arrived at the conclusion that the clutch is not up to the job but the gearbox, which is not noted for its' power handling, will be ok. Personally, I think neither clutch nor box are up to the job. I appreciate that swapping to an 02A or 02J box will mean extra hassle and extra expense, but I don't reckon the 020 box will last long.wicca said:...why change it before it breaks???...
hopkinsgm said:Apologies wicca - it was not my intention to upset you, wind you up or whatever. An 020 may well hold together if you drive sedately and the turbo is not too brutal as it comes on boost. Or it may not. I have my concerns about how well an 020 will handle the power. As an engineer, I tend to be rather conservative where such things are concerned - i'd rather overspecify something and have a safety factor in hand than underspecify something and have it fail prematurely.
However, as it is your car, it is down to you what you will do with it, and how you will drive it. As you say, if the 'box proves to be a weak point, you can always uprate it at a later date if need be.
wicca said:look mate
the 020 box is not strong - but it is reliable.... not as the O2J though...
we all know when VW built the G60 series in all form whent to the cable change
02x type of boxes - which even look massive.
My point of view is as follows
I am building a daily driver - with about 250whp , or even maybe less.... I have no idea what the setup i have would give - I can only guess. what I want is a torquey kind of power all the way to about 6000 rpm. That is why I chose a relatively small turbo with quick spool. I want economy as well - when not pressing hard.
I am going to take care of this car - it is not a drag racer , nor it is to be abused. It means slow careful starts, not pressing much in 1st and 2ond.... more like roll on starts. That is why I am saying - I hope it would hold!!!
If it breaks of course I will change to cable box - the hassle is a bit too much - for me right now - and to do this swap I need the pedal box, the gearshift linkage, clutch assembly, and so much other stuff - If I have to I will do it.
My POV is that 020 in turbo cars has both lasted and has not....... and I reckon is down to driving style.... and it's limit is about 250ft/lbs as far as I know
to say the least it is my least concern at the moment.
getting the whole setup to work is a bigger concern right now.
wicca said:My point of view is as follows
I am building a daily driver - with about 250whp , or even maybe less.... I have no idea what the setup i have would give - I can only guess. what I want is a torquey kind of power all the way to about 6000 rpm. That is why I chose a relatively small turbo with quick spool. I want economy as well - when not pressing hard.
wicca said:the 1.8T with 9.5 comp ratio there is not much you can acheve with standard internals ... that turbo is too small ( KO3) - and you have to start all over again - pistons, manifold turbo, intercooler, ..... I find it a waste of money.
ibizacupra said:I beg to differ
turbo swap and its 350bhp level if you wish. no internal mods req'd from sensible boost levels.
wicca said:With all my respect -
1.8t are not very common in Bulgaria so sourcing such an engine is too much hassle - especially with its gearbox and ECU. Include the turbo upgrade - manifold injectors and remap...... that would be expensive to what I am to do .
I would be better off with buying 1.8t Cupra.....
My idea is to do that project by myself - aas much as I can ... rebuilding the engine in the process and adding a turbo conversion.... I have a passion to work on my car and personalise it.
it is done for passion , and not horsepower in the sense of creating the fastest SX out there.
I understand that there are a few pitfalls in my project - but it is better to know about them and seeing a way of getting around them, rather than ignoring them.
My project will not end up with the turbo conversion alone - the gearbox problems are a major worry to me .... and I will get areoud them at a later stage....
lets see what happens
wicca said:"Originally Posted by wicca
the 1.8T with 9.5 comp ratio there is not much you can acheve with standard internals ... that turbo is too small ( KO3) - and you have to start all over again - pistons, manifold turbo, intercooler, ..... I find it a waste of money. "
You would need to check some ratios out for 02x boxes.. I use an 02A CDA box in my ibiza, which is slightly shorter geared than my 02A box was. VR6 02A's are long legged ratios like my 02J ibiza 20vt box. Get shafts off ibiza 20vt, CV's same as 16v model. 228mm clutch on 02A/J, lots of choice of uprated units. I run Spec stage 3+ for reference.wicca said:Thanks guys!!!
'Thanks for the support - I hope it holds together for the initial stages of the project - next winter I would go to 02x box most probably.....
please can someone tell me what I need off the junkyard to do this swap???
Is it gearbox, pedalbox, gearshift linkage only ???? or I need the change driveshafts/joints??? I am not very sure.... please help ...
I will bolt up the 020.... hope it hold up for summer and 0.5 bar boost ...
LSD and Strong clutch i am better off saving up for the 'cable change box - right???
ibizacupra - please help
Am I better off with a Passat G60 cable box - lower gearing? or Golf3 2.0 16v box???
also there are some 6 speed conversions for the 02x???? are they expensive???? something off the brakeyard???
ibizacupra said:You would need to check some ratios out for 02x boxes.. I use an 02A CDA box in my ibiza, which is slightly shorter geared than my 02A box was. VR6 02A's are long legged ratios like my 02J ibiza 20vt box. Get shafts off ibiza 20vt, CV's same as 16v model. 228mm clutch on 02A/J, lots of choice of uprated units. I run Spec stage 3+ for reference.
You will need the cable selector mechanism, ibiza 20vt is a good model to poach from, same as mk4 gti golf, convert clutch to same cable type as on 16v ibiza, with brackets to suit.
6spd are expensive. I have quaife 6spd dog box, Seqshift in Cz have gear kits tho, as do the likes of Drenth. 6spd 02M is big and very very heavy... wont fit straight in as g'box mount onto subframe would need to be moved.
Find a dead 1.8t ibiza or golf IV and rob its box and selectors.. be as good a starting place as any.
good luck
Billibizacupra said:
hopkinsgm said:Bill
Just to clarify and avoid potential headaches for wicca - when you say "16v Ibiza", are you referring to 2.0 16v (ABF) or 1.8 16v (ADL) here? I assume you mean 2.0 16v, but would be useful if you could confirm.