i feel in love with my boc, i love mine in every way... the biggest thing i love is zero rattles, coming from a corsa thats one big thing i wanted.
i did give the 200 a bit of thought, but apart from the insurance and mpg as you have already stated, i wasnt keen on the car... like the fact its 197ps not bhp... which means power wise their on par. The boc has much better usable power. i friend of mine who works at Renault informs me the clio and the megane both come in about a week after delivery because of squeaky seats, especially the recaro's. That would drive me mad!!!
The cup is the cheaper car as well as its not got A/C etc