k1 milltek turbo back worth it?

Poverty

Guest
This was on a dyno dynamics RR which if you like are classed as 'tight' RR's compared to others,

yeah but my mate had a stage 2 megane untill recently which kicked out the same hp. Alsobackdraft motorsport tune both the megane and k04 based VAG's and show the same results.

Also its not the dyno as such its how the dyno dynamics operator carries out the test. Its well documented that the ko4 based cars are top of the food chain for gains increases on the stock turbo, only the focus RS can match it, but it doesnt make the same massive power increase over standard as the ko4 based VAG units.
 

Poverty

Guest
i think non res + sports cat might be a touch loud, i hit 36 on thursday !

its really not that loud at all tbh mate, its quiet when just driving normally, and gets louder when giving it some, but its still not really loud. Alot of people on here reckon the non res milltek tbe is still too quiet.
 

robdf2

Yellow is the best
Feb 21, 2006
3,605
2
location , location
im 39 ! , im going for miltek downpipe and cat and the rest of the system standard.
should get a bit more nise and free up a few horses too.
 

Carr20vt

Full Member
Dec 18, 2003
952
0
South Wales
Visit site
its really not that loud at all tbh mate, its quiet when just driving normally, and gets louder when giving it some, but its still not really loud. Alot of people on here reckon the non res milltek tbe is still too quiet.

I find mine really loud. Get it out the garage in the morn and it wakes the street up! :whistle:
Do any of you get bad vibrations through the brake pedal when you lift off. Its like the massive back pressure causes my brake pedal to vibrate like mad!
I've just got hold of a non res center to try.
 

luke07cupra

Wind the boost up...
Apr 13, 2009
217
0
Leeds
yep like it being slightly, slightly, ever so slightly slower than a e46 m3 and standard evo 7.

Faster than the new focus RS though etc.

On stage 1 with the boost up at 8 an Evo MR340 was the equivalent and believe me there was NOTHING in it.

All my graphs done on Dyno Dynamics too which are supposed to be conservative anyway...
 
Last edited:

Blade

Full Member
Aug 31, 2004
1,378
28
Teesside
im 39 ! , im going for miltek downpipe and cat and the rest of the system standard.
should get a bit more nise and free up a few horses too.

Milltek don,t recommend that route as the standard back box is way too restrictive to take advantage of the extra your getting from the d/p+cat
 

Poverty

Guest
im 39 ! , im going for miltek downpipe and cat and the rest of the system standard.
should get a bit more nise and free up a few horses too.

Get milltek dp and get the rest done at a custom place when funds allow ;)

I find mine really loud. Get it out the garage in the morn and it wakes the street up! :whistle:
Do any of you get bad vibrations through the brake pedal when you lift off. Its like the massive back pressure causes my brake pedal to vibrate like mad!
I've just got hold of a non res center to try.

Really I think the milltek is like how it should have come out the factory, and aftermarket louder still. Must be because im surronded by mainly japanese cars and vxrs.

On stage 1 with the boost up at 8 an Evo MR340 was the equivalent and believe me there was NOTHING in it.

All my graphs done on Dyno Dynamics too which are supposed to be conservative anyway...

Cool man, not standing starts obviously I take it, only had plays with the evo standing start which destroyed me, then didnt even near red in third when the evo driver decided he was done playing as I obviously wasnt a match :rolleyes::censored:

Next time gonna tell him he we should do a rolling start, once my hpfp is on. [B)]
 

luke07cupra

Wind the boost up...
Apr 13, 2009
217
0
Leeds
Oh ye it was a rolling start from bottom end of 2nd gear through 3rd then into 4th for a bit before shutting off.

Ye from a standing start there would probably be much less powerful FWD cars that could keep up off the mark due to traction issues with FWD and circa 300bhp. Anti lift and sticky tyres needed...
 

Poverty

Guest
Oh ye it was a rolling start from bottom end of 2nd gear through 3rd then into 4th for a bit before shutting off.

Ye from a standing start there would probably be much less powerful FWD cars that could keep up off the mark due to traction issues with FWD and circa 300bhp. Anti lift and sticky tyres needed...

WALK helps with straightline traction?
 

robdf2

Yellow is the best
Feb 21, 2006
3,605
2
location , location
Milltek don,t recommend that route as the standard back box is way too restrictive to take advantage of the extra your getting from the d/p+cat

of course they wont , loose out on money.
they say the downpipe is most restrictive , wish they would make their minds up :think:
 

luke07cupra

Wind the boost up...
Apr 13, 2009
217
0
Leeds
of course they wont , loose out on money.
they say the downpipe is most restrictive , wish they would make their minds up :think:

Ye my understanding was that the main restriction was in the downpipe and CAT. Maybe thats why Milltek make that part of the system 3" then the rest 2.75" :shrug:
 

robdf2

Yellow is the best
Feb 21, 2006
3,605
2
location , location
Ye my understanding was that the main restriction was in the downpipe and CAT. Maybe thats why Milltek make that part of the system 3" then the rest 2.75" :shrug:

there is a guy on the S3 forums who has done this with no problems at all , worst case is i would have to buy the rest of the exhaust , so nothing to loose by trying it and any money saved is a bonus.

i had a quick look under the car and the standard exhaust cat back is pretty solid , its going to go over time any way they always do , in fact this is my second exhaust :whistle:
 

warren_cox

Back from the dead
there is a guy on the S3 forums who has done this with no problems at all

I know someone with over 450bhp in an 8P S3 who has done the same with no ill effect.

It raises a very big question, as to what is recommended by companies / tuners and what is actually FACTUAL, as this can be open to some interpretation.

I run stage 2 in my S3. I should have a DP/TBE, which is on the cards, but I will do it as and when I am ready, and not because I'm being pressured. I'll agree, exhausts are a restrictive point on modern cars when modified, but part of that restriction can be based around ensuring that an OEM car will have significant torque figures for daily driving (and noise suppression).

As soon as you enlarge the exhaust bore diameter you lose some back pressure in the system. Years ago I did it in an 8v 1.9 litre TSR Donington Golf GTi Mk2. I went for a full stainless system 3 inch diameter and whilst at the top end (nearly 3 figures speeds) it would flow well and enabled better speed incremental increase, in the mid range I lost some 50-80 overtaking power as the engine just didn't have the torque of a turbo engine.

Whilst exiting exhaust gases is an important part of the equation, on a £ per BHP ratio I don't think they offer good VFM. I think you get better results from air intake / fulling increase / remap and more often than not forgotten, COOLING mechanisms.

Milltek has become a bit of a badge of honour of late, and on many sites (flame suit goes on). In a year where I've heard of quite a few cracking / failing its not the last word in exhausts, and likewise whilst I will happily concede they sound fantastic and do make a performance improvement, this time (I had a full Milltek TBE with 100cell race cats on my last car), I am going to try something different as I was not that convinced of the benefits for the cost of the product. I'm going back to Ian Birch at Pipewerx to see what he can cook up when I decide to get the S3 exhaust done next year. (Flame suit off, and runs for the exit).
 

robdf2

Yellow is the best
Feb 21, 2006
3,605
2
location , location
I know someone with over 450bhp in an 8P S3 who has done the same with no ill effect.

It raises a very big question, as to what is recommended by companies / tuners and what is actually FACTUAL, as this can be open to some interpretation.

I run stage 2 in my S3. I should have a DP/TBE, which is on the cards, but I will do it as and when I am ready, and not because I'm being pressured. I'll agree, exhausts are a restrictive point on modern cars when modified, but part of that restriction can be based around ensuring that an OEM car will have significant torque figures for daily driving (and noise suppression).

As soon as you enlarge the exhaust bore diameter you lose some back pressure in the system. Years ago I did it in an 8v 1.9 litre TSR Donington Golf GTi Mk2. I went for a full stainless system 3 inch diameter and whilst at the top end (nearly 3 figures speeds) it would flow well and enabled better speed incremental increase, in the mid range I lost some 50-80 overtaking power as the engine just didn't have the torque of a turbo engine.

Whilst exiting exhaust gases is an important part of the equation, on a £ per BHP ratio I don't think they offer good VFM. I think you get better results from air intake / fulling increase / remap and more often than not forgotten, COOLING mechanisms.

Milltek has become a bit of a badge of honour of late, and on many sites (flame suit goes on). In a year where I've heard of quite a few cracking / failing its not the last word in exhausts, and likewise whilst I will happily concede they sound fantastic and do make a performance improvement, this time (I had a full Milltek TBE with 100cell race cats on my last car), I am going to try something different as I was not that convinced of the benefits for the cost of the product. I'm going back to Ian Birch at Pipewerx to see what he can cook up when I decide to get the S3 exhaust done next year. (Flame suit off, and runs for the exit).

Flamesuit not required Warren , you are someone who has proved that you dont need to follow everyone else.
Of course if people like Miltek dont do the advertising with all the blurb and if you do this you get :) but if you dont do it you get :(
I am like you , i see the exhaust as consumable item , but as stated the downpipe is supposed to be the most restrictive part so i am going to change it.
i would like a power increase giving a smooth torque curve and if that can be achieved going this way then im quids in.

btw "8v 1.9 litre TSR Donington Golf GTi Mk2" thats a mouthfull !

I remember when blueflame were all the rage , then there was some quailty problems with them and people started bad mouthing them , we do live in a vain and fickle world where name and brand matters , so we will see what happens , btw good constructive post ;)
 
Adrian Flux insurance services - discount for forum members.