i had this decision to make about a year and a half ago
i in the end went for a john cooper works mini s (210 bhp) great car great performance and handling just not big enough in the end. so sold that after 6 months and now have had a golf gti mk5 for 9 months alls i can say is that it is a cracking car. Dont get me wrong some people have had probs with them i have a couple of minor niggles but all in all love it, after the lcr i didt think i would find anything as good but have twice, both in different ways. Some people will say that the golf isnt worth the extra of some rivals inc the lcr but the interior is (in my opinion a nicer place to be) not a dig at the lcr by any means, the engine is superb smoother than the mini and lcr and feels just as fast as the lcr not quite as fast as the mini and the handling i was very surprised at, i was expecting to be disapoined after the mini but although not quite up there with the mini very good.
Anyway waffled enough that ismy 2pence worth
,