On my old pd150 hybrid I used a panel filter kn, a bmc cda, and a jetex cone. The cone gave me the best power and the best throttle response. Between that and the intake sits a bloody great big intercooler. You cant compare against different makes of cars as that's not very scientific. Ford tdci intercoolers are frankly so small it's funny.
Ideally I'd experiment with multiple intake systems on the same car and use a dyno to measure the differences between each, but time and money prevents this. My day job isn't car tuning!
However, the guy at Autospeed caried out lots of pressure drop testing of different intake systems and his results convinced me that the actual filter element in most cases made very little difference to the overall pressure drop through the entire air inlet / airbox system.
The Ford IC was smaller than the front mount fitted to the VW 150hp 1.9 PD engine, but larger than that fitted to the 130hp versions. It was a sort of semi-top-mount though which meant that hot air could pass through it from the engine bay when the car was stationary, heating the core. When moving, the air scoop passed cold air over the core and into the engine bay.