Have to disagree on the price differential though as it is clear discounts are possible on the Cupra too (quite a few on here have bought well under list). Like everyone else who is / was looking at the Cupra I also considered the S3, didn't really consider the Golf R as the styling doesn't do much for me.
etc.
Yes, it seems a few people are in the same boat. Ultimately the S3, the Golf and the Cupra are always going to be very similar. Same platform, same engine. Oddly, it's the little things that make the difference. I know I could have probably shopped around on the Cupra but ultimately the Golf was top of the list, slightly ahead of the Cupra. I do also like my local SEAT dealership.
So for what it's worth here were my thoughts and observations.
The Cupra has come so far since the last model, even post-facelift. The interior is a really nice place to be. However, it does still lag behind the Golf and the S3. The dash still seems big with empty plastic, although it's nothing compared to the old models. The door cards also seem cheap compared with the others. The seats/wheel/general driver stuff are no better or worse than the others, however.
The styling of the Cupra is really going to divide people. The angles on the air vents are very out of place nowadays and for some reason when I first got in,
this reminded me (perhaps unfairly) of
this. Others may not see it, and I'm showing my age, I know.
The exterior styling also divides opinion. Personally I love the way the Leon looks. I also like the understated look of the Cupra, compared with the rest of the range. The Golf wins for me though. May be a bit less interesting, but it's a handsome car.
The Cupra also seems to have more room in the front than the Golf, although I think that's just the centre console of the Golf which makes the difference. The rest of the interior in the Golf is a class above in my opinion, as it is with the S3. I know others won't care in the slightest. The S3 has the sat-nav screen which rises out of the dash and has no touch-screen. Not as bad as the nasty affair that BMW put in theirs.
The Golf has much more rear legroom, thanks to some clever front seats which are hollowed out at the back. Boot space in the Leon wins though, having no rear drive train to take up space.
As for driving it, well confession time: I've not actually driven an R. I've only driven a GTD. I've driven an S3 and have been in a Cupra twice: once driving and once being thrown around in the back of one with blacked-out windows at Sheerness docks. I hated the S3. The suspension was rock solid; worse than my
Ibiza FR. The Cupra was great, with comfort mode being a good match for crappy British road surfaces. I'm putting faith in the fact that the Golf will feel the same.
Then there's the residuals. Personally I think the Cupra will hold its value much better than previous models. The quality's much closer to the competition than previously. I reckon that both cars would cost me about the same over a few years and given I have the dosh and am paying cash (did I mention that I'm getting on a bit?) then it's the Golf for me.
I'll probably still lurk around here though. I like this forum. Besides, I have an
Ibiza FR tdi to sell. May 2004, one owner from new. 90K miles. No mods. Make me an offer
![Smile :) :)]()