• Guest would you be interested in CUPRA or SEAT valve caps? let us know in the poll

  • Welcome to our new sponsor Lecatona, a brand dedicated to enhancing performance for VAG group sports cars, including SEAT, Audi, Volkswagen and Škoda. Specializing in High Pressure Fuel Pump (HPFP) upgrades.

Ibiza spare wheel....

evoy2k2

Active Member
May 30, 2007
208
0
Wolverhampton!
I currently have 17" alloys on my ibiza, but my spare wheel is 16". I no that its not a good idea to put spare on if i have puncture etc.

Will i need a 17" alloy or can i just put a larger/bigger tyre on the 16" spare?

Been told you can do this, but im not so sure:shrug:
 

Gooner_Mike

Teaching the kids
Jan 20, 2008
4,363
2
Hampshire
www.facebook.com
If the spare tyre is the one that came with the car then you will be fine. Did you upgrade to 17" and now run 40 profile tyres? When you go up a size of wheel (16" to 17") you should also reduce the profile (45 to 40) to keep the rolling radius of the wheel the same!
 

Aimez

Active Member
Alot of cars have space saver/get me home wheels so can't see what the problem would be, unfortunately I am currently running with one 16 on and the rest 17 but have no choice as my wheel was bent after hitting a pot hole but it's only for 2 days and the furthest I have driven is the the wheel refurbishment place. I take it that is what you are asking as seems odd you would ask if your spare was the same size as your other wheels?
 
Last edited:

tkjeeves

Blue
Jul 13, 2008
333
0
oxford
its better than a wafer thin "space saver"... if you're really wanting the same wheel then there are some places you can get apart from the dealer of course, ebay is probably where i would start
 

evoy2k2

Active Member
May 30, 2007
208
0
Wolverhampton!
If the spare tyre is the one that came with the car then you will be fine. Did you upgrade to 17" and now run 40 profile tyres? When you go up a size of wheel (16" to 17") you should also reduce the profile (45 to 40) to keep the rolling radius of the wheel the same![/QUO

Well when i had the car, i swapped my 17" alloys over and they are now 40 profile tyres. Jus my spare wheel is the standard 16". Im not using the spare now, just somthing i wanted to ask just incase i need the spare. Obviously its gna be uneven running 3 17" and a 16". Its a tdi sport 100bhp
 

Aimez

Active Member
You won't be saying cool when you have to change 2 wheels when you are stressed out in a hurry and changing a wheel in the rain or dark with the crappy standard jack and the wheel nuts torqued at a million nm! Flats never occur in easy situations it seems! But he has a sport and the spare is obviously standard so it's okay
Driving with one 16 on at the mo feels a bit weird and uneven how come people are saying this is fine?
 

evoy2k2

Active Member
May 30, 2007
208
0
Wolverhampton!
You won't be saying cool when you have to change 2 wheels when you are stressed out in a hurry and changing a wheel in the rain or dark with the crappy standard jack and the wheel nuts torqued at a million nm! Flats never occur in easy situations it seems! But he has a sport and the spare is obviously standard so it's okay
Driving with one 16 on at the mo feels a bit weird and uneven how come people are saying this is fine?

Ive been told not to even put the spare (16") on, as its not safe for long distances etc! Some people say its ok and others say not 2 even bother lol:shrug:
 
Oct 17, 2006
2,141
0
Mid Wales
You won't be saying cool when you have to change 2 wheels when you are stressed out in a hurry and changing a wheel in the rain or dark with the crappy standard jack and the wheel nuts torqued at a million nm! Flats never occur in easy situations it seems! But he has a sport and the spare is obviously standard so it's okay
Driving with one 16 on at the mo feels a bit weird and uneven how come people are saying this is fine?

Using a tyre size calculator, it would seem that your new wheels with tyres (assuming you're running 205/40 R17) will stand 0.2" taller than stock, meaning the hub will sit 0.1" higher from the ground than it did as standard.

This means that with the old spare on one corner of the car is 0.1" lower - to be honest I'd be amazed if you can actually feel this - I'd imagine it's more likely psychological - because you know the spares on and it's a different size you think it must feel odd

Ive been told not to even put the spare (16") on, as its not safe for long distances etc! Some people say its ok and others say not 2 even bother lol:shrug:

As long as the tyres are correctly sized to give as close as possible the same rolling radius, then you'll be fine.

My old Fiesta came with 15" alloys and a 14" spare as standard - no problem there.

My A3 has 16" alloys and an 18" space saver spare - again no problems as the rolling radius is matched.

It's probably advisable not to run over 50 mph or for longer than say 50 miles (as is normally advised in the manuals of cars with mismatched spares) as if there is a slight difference in rolling radius the resulting difference in rotational speed will confuse the ABS system causing a fault to be logged.
 
Last edited:

Gooner_Mike

Teaching the kids
Jan 20, 2008
4,363
2
Hampshire
www.facebook.com
Ive been told not to even put the spare (16") on, as its not safe for long distances etc! Some people say its ok and others say not 2 even bother lol:shrug:

Why would they put a spare in the car then? Its not as if its one of those space saver ones. If your worried, get a can of that puncture repair foam stuff! Good for emergencies.
 

Aimez

Active Member
BOOOO I'm stuck running my spare until Wednesday now as my bent wheel had more damage under the tyre so been sent away. Maybe it is in my head it feels different, yes I am running 205/40/17 and the spare steel alloy. But I don't wan to drive far with it so won't be going anywhere this weekend. I could put my 4 Seat alloys on but really can't be arsed getting the wheel nuts off and maybe knocking the paint on them again!
 
Adrian Flux insurance services - discount for forum members.