Mot Failed on noise!!

orbital45uk

Guest

• Jul 4, 2009

• #1

Last week i had to take the Leon down for its MOT, Its passed every year with the same Piper exhaust with the sports cat but this year its failed because its to loud!!.

What a pain in the arse, When did this come change in the mot come in?

Does anyone have a standard system that i may borrow for the MOT??

 

Willie

LCR Track car

Aug 6, 2004

8,939

1

Sunny Scotland

• Jul 4, 2009

• #2

What levels arr acceptable and what level was your car?
What CAT do you have 200 or 100 CELL??

 

orbital45uk

Guest

• Jul 4, 2009

• #3

The refusal of an MOT certificate says

Exhaust noise is cn average clearly in excess of that emitted by a similar vehicle fitted with a standard silencer in average condition

I'm running with a 100 cell CAT

It doesnt say if there is an exceptable db limit

 

Willie

LCR Track car

Aug 6, 2004

8,939

1

Sunny Scotland

• Jul 4, 2009

• #4

Must be a judgement call from the assessor

 

orbital45uk

Guest

• Jul 4, 2009

• #5

Realy so if i took it back to the place its been passed before they would pass it??

Its just the preference of the tester

 

CupraUK

Pushing on

Aug 15, 2005

1,350

0

Bedfordshire

• Jul 4, 2009

• #6

Possibily. My missus' 106 once failed on "brake discs too thin". When questioned on his ability to read thousandths of a mm with his eye, he backed down and passed it

 

LEE69

Stage 2 Revo'd

Dec 10, 2004

21,262

74

C\UK\Devon\Torquay

• Jul 4, 2009

• #7

Willie said:

Must be a judgement call from the assessor

Click to expand...

Yeah it is exactly that, based on the noise of a similar standard car.

Try another mot cente for advice on the noise, some will pass it, some won't.

 

adam cupra 20vt

Built Not Bought.

Mar 31, 2005

6,162

2

Mud Hut

• Jul 4, 2009

• #8

As Lee said try another centre, none of my cars ever failed on noise and I had some noisy bits of crap when i was younger

 

Faisal

UK's 1st Liquid Yello LCR

May 27, 2008

1,445

0

Most likely at work

• Jul 4, 2009

• #9

good thing i never took my saxo to guys like these. they'd need earmuffs if they wanted to test the sound.dont thnk i'd pass with flying colours either

 

strugers1

Guest

• Jul 4, 2009

• #10

my car is over 100 ecibels on the tester and it passes with no problem
mine is a diesel and its stupi loud

 

m0rk

sarcasm comes free

Staff member

May 19, 2001

27,787

33

Clanfield, UK

• Jul 4, 2009

• #11

New rules for this year... they're failling more & more cars on noisey exhausts

It is only a perception, so you could argue the case.

 

strugers1

Guest

• Jul 4, 2009

• #12

i going to the same garage lol so ill say you passed it last year nothings changed!!

 

Willie

LCR Track car

Aug 6, 2004

8,939

1

Sunny Scotland

• Jul 4, 2009

• #13

strugers1 said:

i going to the same garage lol so ill say you passed it last year nothings changed!!

Click to expand...

Good thinking!!

 

m0rk

sarcasm comes free

Staff member

May 19, 2001

27,787

33

Clanfield, UK

• Jul 4, 2009

• #14

strugers1 said:

i going to the same garage lol so ill say you passed it last year nothings changed!!

Click to expand...

It has changed!

Method of inspection:
assess subjectively the effectiveness of the silencer in reducing exhaust noise to a level considered to be average for the vehicle.

Reason for Rejection:
a silencer in such condition, or of such a type, that the noise emitted from the vehicle is clearly unreasonably above the level expected from a similar vehicle with a silencer in average condition.

Basically - they may fail it if the tester feels that it's too noisy for a similar vehicle. Not the same vehicle 12 months ago

 

strugers1

Guest

• Jul 4, 2009

• #15

oh i see!! is there not a legal limit for the roa?? cos i would have thought if its loud but under the legal limit for the road it cant be failed??
i might be wrong but seems silly to fail it if its under the legal limit..
a bit like your tires look too worn its a fail yet measure above the legal limit??
or am i way off lol

 

m0rk

sarcasm comes free

Staff member

May 19, 2001

27,787

33

Clanfield, UK

• Jul 4, 2009

• #16

It's a subjective fail... but it's based on your car as standard

Basically - VOSA are responding to the wishes of the majority of people who are pissed off with the chavs running about with noisey exhausts at 2am.

Now I'm sure you don't fall into that category, but the reasoning behind it is that your car was type approved with a certain sound level & that's roughly what they're looking for.

If you don't agree with the MOT tester, contact VOSA & they'll check it for you. And you'll still fail

 

strugers1

Guest

• Jul 4, 2009

• #17

oh i see!!!bloody old people lol

 

BBoy82

Dan the compressor man...

Oct 25, 2008

293

0

East Northants

• Jul 4, 2009

• #18

Hmm. I think ill order a resonated blueflame when i get round to it... Cant be arsed with all this hastle!

 

wild willy

Full Member

Aug 4, 2003

2,323

0

Wales

• Jul 4, 2009

• #19

I can't believe this. A maximum limit must be in place surely, to be measured with a calibrated sound meter at x distance. Someone's opinion is a joke as we all percieve sound levels differently........ this could only happen in the motor trade.
I do appreciate the clamp down on excessively noisey exhausts though.

 

wild willy

Full Member

Aug 4, 2003

2,323

0

Wales

• Jul 4, 2009

• #20

BBoy82 said:

Hmm. I think ill order a resonated blueflame when i get round to it... Cant be arsed with all this hastle!

Click to expand...

I have one mate and it is LOUD.