MOT advisory on tyres

exmgman

Active Member
Nov 30, 2009
78
8
18 plate Leon FR 1.8 Tsi.
I have had the following advisory from a recent MOT test For all 4 tyres
“Tyres slightly damaged/ cracking or perishing”
Tyres are Bridgestone Tuaranza 225/45 R17 dated 0723 fitted February 2023.
Granted they are 2 years old but have only covered 13,000 miles and currently tread depth is 5.0/5.5 mm front and 6.0/6.5mm rear.
So there is some life left in them. I never run tyres down to the legal limits.
As an ex Motorsport competitor I replace tyres when the feedback and feel of lack of grip becomes apparent regardless of tread depth.
I raised a complaint with Bridgestone and received the following response.
How would other members feel about this?
There is sufficient damage to warrant an advisory from the official MOT inspection.
I wonder what my insurer would think about this in the event of a claim?
Comments welcomed.

From Bridgestone:-
“The cracking evident on the tyres is due to oxidation of the rubber, which causes the rubber to become more brittle, and crack under stress. Ageing of the rubber is accelerated by exposure to certain factors, such as sunlight, sea air, contaminants (including tyre blacking agents), and ozone (which can come from motor exhaust and electrical motors). The effects of ageing are particularly noted when the vehicle is parked up for periods Oulf of time, and the anti-ageing oils and agents on the surface of the tyre are broken down or washed off, and not replenished from within the tyre by the tyre’s movement. Also, oxidation of the tyre is possible when the rubber is under stress, the more stress the tyre is under, the more likely the tyre will suffer from oxidation. Tyres which are run with insufficient pressure are more likely to crack in this manner.

Tyre manufacturers add ingredients to rubber compounds to slow down the rate at which tyres age. However, conditions of storage and use (including tyre maintenance) have a larger influence over the tyre aging process. Tyres that are used infrequently (low mileage) and/or in coastal areas will age more quickly. Low usage prevents the anti-ageing oils from migrating to the tread surface (oil replenishment at the tread surface is diminished), so causing the tyres to display surface rubber cracking.
From the images you have provided, I can confirm that in their current state we would recommend that you continue using the tyres, as the surface rubber cracking is not compromising tyre safety or the tyres dynamic characteristics. The presence of perishing is not unusual of any tyre over 12 months old since the date of manufacture, the presence of perishing alone does not indicate that the tyre needs to be replaced.”

Apart from the visual appearance of surface cracking the tyres are safe for continued use. However, as with all tyres, you should check tyres regularly for any signs of significant damage or deterioration.”
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0413.jpeg
    IMG_0413.jpeg
    89.6 KB · Views: 52
  • IMG_0415.jpeg
    IMG_0415.jpeg
    173.7 KB · Views: 50

exmgman

Active Member
Nov 30, 2009
78
8
Hmm that doesnt look very good. Did you follow the recommended tyre pressures?
Of course. As I said in the original post as an ex Motorsport competitor tyre pressures and fluid levels are checked frequently.
This is the reason for concern regarding tyre condition. The scrutineer commenting on the condition of the car.
 

nd-photo.nl

Active Member
Mar 6, 2012
3,986
200
The Netherlands
youtube.com
Ah yes, my bad. Then it looks like failure from the manufacturer. For me that would be the decision to not choose tyres from that manufacturer anymore.

I havent experienced this with fairly new tyres in all my car driving years, but to be honest I never had Bridgestone tyres :unsure:
 

RUM4MO

Active Member
Jun 4, 2008
8,011
1,086
South Scotland
Hankook also can suffer from this "early life" cracking, though I think that Hankook have addressed this issue, VW Group do fit Hankook at factories but I'd expect that they will not worry about this happening to owner's cars - price/cost is king!

To OP, I'd think that you'd prefer never to find this happening on any tyres fitted to your cars, my younger daughter and her husband asked me about this after buying a used Arona, I suggested that as they had noticed this cracking on the rear tyres - car came to them with new front tyres, a newer version of Hankook, that they plan to replace both rear tyres with a pair that match the fronts and expect that these newer versions give a longer "good looking" service life - as with them, it will never be the tread wear that forces replacement as they use local rail services (living in Bromley) as possible as well as walking.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Seriously?

Seriously?

Active Member
Apr 20, 2018
1,360
936
Not Bridgestone, but Hankooks (as mentioned by RUM4MO above) did the same on our Leon.
Contrary to Mr Bridgestone's written explanation that you quote in your post, our car lives 15 miles inland, gets used everyday and never has the tyres treated with a dressing product.
 

SuperV8

Active Member
May 30, 2019
1,669
785
I bet you can find examples of all tyre brands having cracking - 'dry rot'. Just google "dry rot + tyre brand" I can see examples from all the big tyre brands.
I had some Nokian winter tyres suffer.
Brigstones response seems reasonably to me. You do have low millage - which can contribute more to cracking/dry rot.
Yours doesn't look severe so I wouldn't worry about it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mo_86
Progressive Parts, performance parts and tuning specialists