@Jimbobcook - good, comprehensive
review. I’m always keen to read
reviews on the current shape
Ibiza as I own a current shape Polo - a GTI+, so although performance comparisons wouldn’t be relevant, I can compare other aspects of my car with the
Ibiza.
I agree 100% on looks - the
Ibiza is a better looking car than the Polo - much more stylish than the Polo, with some interesting design cues. If Seat had produced a Cupra version of the
Ibiza, then there’s a really good chance I’d be driving a Cupra now rather than a GTI
. The FR’s alloys have great showroom appeal for most prospective buyers. However, I dislike diamond cut alloys with a passion (poor durability of finish, easily damaged by tyre fitters, more expensive to refurbish than powder coated alloys). My favourite alloys were the 17” version on the pre facelift FR; I liked the design and they were painted / powder coated, so they were good for all round use on a car that’s used as a daily driver as they’d stand well up to all weather / road conditions. My car came with 18” diamond cut alloys and Bridgestone tyres but it doesn’t have either now!
I would have much preferred the Conti Sport Contact 5’s that were fitted to your test car. I have Michelin PS4 tyres on my replacement wheels and IMHO they are certainly better than the Bridgestones.
The facelift
Ibiza FR’s interior looks good but I agree with you on the air vent surrounds and I think they cheapen the interior of the car. If the vent surrounds had been black or dark grey without those little bumps they would’ve been better IMHO. I prefer the climate control panel in the facelift
Ibiza to the the latest touch panel version in the VW Polo; the
Ibiza’s will be much easier to use while driving than the Polo’s version. Interesting that Seat don’t have a RHD version of the gear leaver surround with the in-use buttons on the driver’s side; the Polo have RHD and LHD versions for specific markets. Agree that an armrest is a strange omission on the top sport model - I have one in my GTI+ and although I don’t use it as an armrest, it finishes off the space between the front seats nicely, and is a useful additional storage pace.
Interesting to hear your comments on seat comfort. The seats in my Polo GTI+ look very comfortable and supportive, but after 16.5 months of ownership, I still find it takes me a while to get comfortable. I’ve not had this in any of the four previous VW’s I’ve owned.
I think VAG’s 1.0 110ps engine with manual transmission is a good combination. My preference would’ve been to have a manual transmission, but it wasn’t available in my GTI+ (car is DSG only). It’s the first non-manual car I’ve owned in over 40 years of driving and it’s fine most of the time, but I still prefer a manual over a DSG / auto so I can decide what gear to use rather than the car decide this for me.
I can’t compare fuel consumption of my car to the
Ibiza FR you were driving as it’d be a bit like comparing apples and pears but for the record, my long term mpg is around 41, which I think is very good for a 2.0 197bhp car.
Overall, I think Seat have done a good job with the facelift of the
Ibiza. If I was in the market for a 1.0 110ps engined car, I’d choose the
Ibiza FR over a Polo R-Line as I think the
Ibiza is a more stylish, better value car. And I’d just learn to live with the red air vent surrounds
. I’d probably change the wheels though………..