As an aside if people start having trouble and complaints as the car gets older it wouldn't be 1 set of tyres older would it?
Tyres make a large difference not just to comfort and noise but also handling. A good tyre will help a bad suspension but a bad tyre... well the welcoming embrace of the ditch awaits those who press hard on poor tyres (or worse). But I guess most on this site know that.
Shock absorbers/dampers what ever you want to call them (if you want to get all physics then absorbing the energy from the system to introduce control or damping does point to dampers but it's personal choice) also make a difference - take a look at the difference in braking distance from worn shocks if you want to scare yourself (and no I don't work for a tyre shop). However I'd be concerned if in 12 months the damping on the car degraded to the point it changed the handling/noise that much.
Drove a few mk5s when looking around and didn't notice any really issues - unlike the MiTo we drove (playstation 3 steering in a car I do not need). Will admit I didn't take the car to the edge - try and avoid doing that sort of thing on the road these days.
Still waiting our mk5 to be delivered - options means long wait given down sizing of the factory throughput........ guess we'll see for ourselves.
i guess you got me wrong it was not the quality of the tyre it was the size of the tyre as 175x70x14 which i am planing to replace with 185x65x15 dude.
Also i would like to inform i am very happy with the steering wheel and etc.
Regards