From reading this and the other threads it proves Henry Ford's adage about all of the people all of the time. Some love the Mk1 and don't like the Mk2, and vice-versa. Same with this I suppose..
Personally, having come from a mark 2 Tolly I thought the Leon 1P (mk2) was a stunning looking car, and still do. I think the Mazda 3 might have just beaten the Altea/Leon to the side window profile, which was soon copied by others (Ford Kuga, Kia Ceed, Hyundai i30) and more recently by some who should know better (Ford Fiesta and Focus). As for this looking like an Astra, I think the new Astra is a carbon copy of the F/L Leon 1p. So if they keep some of the mk2 style, no wonder it looks like the competition..
I much prefer the look of the pre-facelift Mk2 than the post F/L, I guess I just like the purer lines. (FR and Cupra excepted..) There were hints of the mk2 styling to come in the last Mk1s, just look at the revised mk1 door mirrors for the Salsa/Mk2/Altea french curves. Likewise the facelift mk2 mirrors and LED lights that are all this edgy straight line stuff, and this car is full of it.
As others, I'm not sure about this one but I have to say it appears to be growing on me. I can also see the influences of both the Mk1 and more so the Mk2 in this. I like the front, not so sure on the rear. Will wait to see one in the flesh to be sure. Having just got a 2010 FR, I guess I'm slightly relieved that they didn't turn out another stunner as I won't likely be changing for at least 3 years. (The 1P came out at the right time, I only had a year to wait...) Also happy for the brand that they didn't turn out another Nissan Joke, sorry, Juke...
To be honest though, I'll probably be just as interested, if not more so, in an Exeo or new Toledo (depending on price and spec) as I will in this.
BTW, am I the only one who thinks the new Hyundai i40 estate is a good looking car?