tdi's dont do well at town journeys. they still manage to slightly beat petrols but the main difference appears on long runs or motorway work. I remember i think it was pbirkett on here had one and didnt like the mpg at all, and it was winter, we swapped in the end for a clio 172 and he was happier, his style of driving and the journey in his case didnt show the TDI as being the better engine.