I didn't check the polarity of the original bulb as I thought they were all the same but the LED's I have are negative body and positive on the bottom pin.
It doesn't matter on your old bulb, incandescent bulbs work either way
I wondered how many terminal on the bottom, anyway I checked its just one
The reason your bulbs don't work is because they are wired the wrong way round for your car, its luck of the draw as to which way they wire them
On cars sometimes the bottom pin is positive sometimes its not, never an issue as a filament bulb can work either way round
Obviously an issue though if you want to fit leds
You could buy some more bulbs, but you may have the same issue
Or cut the wires and swap them round (not recommended)
If it was me, I would find the two indicator wires going into the plug on the light cluster, carefully remove the pins and swap the wires over, you can get the pin removal tools for a few pounds or use a couple of small watchmakers screwdrivers
Or if your handy with a soldering iron, remove the head from your led bulb base and swap the wires over, depending what sort of led bulbs they are they come apart quite easily