Goodyear Asymmetric or Excellence quietest?

[nc30rider]

Time for new tyres, and mytyres.net are doing 8% off at the mo.
Deffo want Goodyear's, had them in the past and cannot fault them.

My question is which one? The excellence or F1 asymmetric

I want the quietest tyres of the two.

I have Pirellis at the mo and the front ones are starting to get down

Cheers!

 

[Poverty]

no idea on excellence, but the goodyears f1s have been quiter than the oem spec tyres I have ever had been stuck with

 

[erichuyn]

Have to agree on the assymetric's! Quieter than falken FK452 and Continental Sportcontact 2.
NO CUPPING, are on my leon's rear axle for about 30k miles and still have many miles to go. Good wheel protection aswell.
According to tyretest.com the assymetric beats the excellence on everything. But those are normal people shouting about tyres on very different cars